All the Pretty Horses

[October 2025] 

All the Pretty Horses, by Cormac McCarthy



Readers: 5

Average rating:  7.6
Highest rating: 8.75
Lowest rating: 6

Overheard:
The pacing was akin to "going for a walk and being forced to slow down" 
"Like being back in AP lit"
The author "assumes you're paying attention" 

Side note:
A 2000 movie version with Matt Damon & Penelope Cruz has a 32% Rotten Tomatoes score. 



The Names

[September 2025] 

The Names, by Florence Knapp 

Readers: 16

Percentage of readers who finished the book: 100%

Average rating:  7.7125
Highest rating: 9.4
Lowest rating: 3

Overheard:
"It was interesting that someone pays with their life in every story" 
"The names were less important than the actions"

Notable discussion point: 
What would it be like to read each timeline separately on its own?

Likely unanimous opinion: 
Well-written! 

Welcome!

Year 23 of the best book club!

You can find our picks for 2025-26 here

You can find our complete list of titles here

Happy reading! 📚