The Ultimate Gift
Jim Stovall
number of voters: 7
percentage of voters who finished the book: 100%
highest rating: 9
lowest rating: 4
average rating: 5.64
number of readers who read the book aloud to their fifth-grade classroom: 1
We were in the fourth year of our book group, when into our midst walked this young book, all full of pomp and purpose. The Ultimate Gift was hoping to inherit our highly desired praise, but little did this swaggering book know that it was about to be put through a series of rigorous tests.
The Test of Story
Things started off well for “Gift.” The story sounded interesting, and we devoured it easily in its bite-size chunks. But it quickly became apparent that this story, while appealing, was nothing more than an undeveloped story idea. Unsatisfactory marks in this category.
The Test of Writing
Again, “Gift” failed to impress. The writing was pedantic and overly simplistic. While it worked well in a classroom setting (Good idea, Stephanie!), as a book for adults the author shoots for the moon and air balls. Lowest marks.
The Test of Content
This was “Gift’s” greatest success. The message was important and thought-provoking. Each chapter had enough content to be a book in and of itself. Highest marks.
The Test of Entertainment
“Gift” was so easy to read and contained such a simple message that we were easily entertained by it. Decent marks in this category.
The Test of Literature
Unfortunately for “Gift,” the lack of quality writing or story pacing ruins its chances to share a shelf with the classics of literature. It may perhaps be better suited to a doctor’s office waiting room.
Summary: A good idea poorly executed. While not a waste of time, The Ultimate Gift leaves a lot to be desired. In the end, does “Gift” receive the inheritance? You’ll have to read it for yourself to find out.
No comments:
Post a Comment